Eval #4

[Rola Saad]

Hello teachers

i emailed all the other teachers , so that all of you would log-in!!!

so..since all the candidates posted the eval .. we'll have a meeting now!!

i need each of u to put their opinion about each candidates + a mark out of 20 for their performance

then i will take the average of each candidate , least 3 averages will be the 3 to be nominated
highest 5 will be the top 5

and .. to let you know..Shahinaz was dismissed for inactivity and she does not want to stay anymore!!!

Thanks Teachers!

[Wadie Abi-Raed]

ok so i will start with group #1
amal b. - as usual she did a good eval , that's what we are used to , but in the lyrics there is this link hanged there ... she just copies without even checking ;D . (17/20)
walid - good eval,it's obvious he knew how to put the scene in the right way & attractive way.he made a huge progress 17/20
diaa - she's not making progress , she is a good candidate though , she has to show more before it's too late ! 13/20
the group in general : was SO GOOD!

group #2 :
lara - she did not post the pictures!! for the song .. she's active and talented though! she did not work alot on the eval!! (10/20)
moustafa - is surprising me , totally changed..much progress!!! & hard worker (20/20)
mohamed - he's not so active , he did not do much to make the eval..mustafa did everything , lara was trying..and he's kinda putting all the work on them!! i did not like that..song posted right anyway!! (11/20)
group in general : not bad

group #3 :
first of all , they did not work together!!!the point from the eval was team work!! so i'm kind of

joseph - 2 pictures only ? why ;D ... the scene was simple
(9/20)
tina - also 2 pictures...incomplete...(9/20)
michel - everything in the song right , good nice pictures to make a nice view .. nothing more!! (10/20)
group in general : if they all worked together , i think overall should have been good...so it's kind of BAD!!

group #4
fady & imane - so simple , i like how the song was included in the scene both (13/20)
group in general : fair

[Alissar Karakalla]

First of all in my opinion group #1 of walid,dia and amal was the best group

walid = although he was safe this week , he worked on the eval and helped his friends . that was night!! it proves that he works alot and ready to work more,he took the scene made by amal & posted it in a nice way!! which proves the team work in this group , each doing their part..from here we come to amal

amal = she is really talented , the scene was simple and so nice.well she has all what it takes to be a star

dia = she did not do much . i want to see more from here

----


group #2
Moustafa did a great job & work and he is making progress
he worked alot on the eval , maybe the only one !!! it was him who made everything .. so simple scene!! and nice in the same time

Lara = only candidate who did not post the pictures .. it's like the only candidate who sang half the song
she came up wit h an idea , but eval is not complete

mohamid = i did not see alot from him in the eval .

----
group #3
ok this is the worst group
no team work , it's like tina & joseph r paired and left michel alone??they could have involved him at least
michel no scene!!!
tina & joe .. added something that was not requested and some pictures are missing
they were asked for 5 pictures
ok the scene is sooooooo simple!!!
michel .. no scene..just a complete song
sorry very bad work!! very bad work!!

-----
group #4
imane & fady..so simple...they just did what they have to do..but i wanted to see how they camup with all this ? ok it seems they did that outside the eval section!


MARKS
walid 17/20
amal b 18/20
dia 12/20
moustafa 20/20
lara 10/20
mohamid 11/20
joe 9/20
tina 9/20
michel 10/20
imane 13/20
fady 13/20

[Gabrielle Yammin]

amal 19/20 ... she did a great scene , walid kind of put the last touch it was a nice team work
diaa 10/20 ... did not see alot from her in the scene
waled 14/20 .... i liked his touch and the things he corrected!!
mostafa 20/20 ... as wadi3 & alisar said,he is making progress.he made a great scene obviously ALONE
ammah 10/20 ... he did not do alot for the scene,in the class not so creative..but at least tried
lara 12/20 ... good candidate,she tried to help mostafa and worked good in the class
fady 12/20 .. simple idea. tried to work in class!!!
imane 12/20 .. simple idea . worked in the class good!!
michel 9/20 ... mark is on pics and words
tina 11/20 ... i liked how they made a simple scene , and how they put it
jozph 11/20 ... the scene was so simple , he is kind of naive in the class..needs alot to do!! and make progress

[Fouad Fadel]

diaa:not much to say!
song made perfect
not much work in the scene
(13)

walid:it's enough he made an eval although his gift is not to do it
he made progress
very very good eval
(19)

amal:i really liked the scene she made,and how walid helped her
there is a link in the middle of the song
(16)

fady & imane : scene good
songs included in the scene in a smart way
good candidates
they may show more in the next days!
both (14)

joe & tina:missing pictures
video is over
why michel is not with them
scene very simple
both (10)

michel:i will judge him alone
everything posted right
nice touch
(14)

moustafa:yes he made progress and it is obvious
(17)

lara:no pictures not even the name of the singer
(6)

mohamid:ok did what he has to do
nothing special
(13)

[Mary Mahfouz]

fady el sowar ely na2ayon ktir mena7
imane el sowar z3'ar ma 3aleh
7abet keef kel wa7ad 3'anna different parts ;D
wel mashad 7elo wo baset
imane:14
fady:14

joseph:sowar na2seh
tina:sowar na2seh
el mashhad kan ktir ktir ktir baset!!
kan a7san law kano eshtghalo wayya michel,ok 7elwe fkret enno yihitto video
joseph:11
tina:11

michel:shakhssyan 7abet el eval ba3rif fi asatzeh ra7 ye3arduny
bas be3t2ed law kan shtaghal ma3 as7abo kan 3imlo she ahssan
michel:14

mohamad:3amal el song mazbout:13
lara:ma fi sowar??? 8
moustafa:el 3'niyyi sah wel sowar ktir kebear wad7een 7eloo
el mashhad ketiiiiiiir 7elo
We thx 3la flowers ento mitl welady
moustafa:20.ma 7ada ra7 ye3ardny kelkon 3atetouh hek ma3 enny kan baddy 3tilo 19 aw 18 bas 3an jad byst7e2 el 20

dia:el song mazbouta wel sowar.talbeh jaydeh! 14
amal b:eh sheft ana hayda el link bel ness 16 , el marra el jaye lazim tentbeh !
walid:bykffy eno kan bi 2aman we 3mal el eval we sa3ad as7abo 20
el mashhad ktiir 7elo

[Rola Saad]

thanks alot teachers!!
tht's how it's gonna be from now one
i will e-mail you,and as soon as u see it
please log in and put ur marks


so i calculated the average for each candidate

Mostafa : 17+20+20+20+20=19,4

Walid : 17+17+14 +19+20 = 17,4

Amal B. : 17+18+19+16+16=17,2

Fady : 14+12+13+13+14=13,2

Imane : 14+12+13+13+14=13,2

Diaa : 13+10+12+13+14=12,4

Mohamed : 11+11+10+13+13=11,6

Michel : 10+10+9+14+14=11,4

Joseph : 10+11+9+9+11=10,0

Tina : 10+11+9+9+11=10,0

Lara : 10+10+12+6+8=9,2




which means that the nominees are : Joseph,Tina & Lara!!!

thank u

[Rola Saad]

i did not put fady in the top 5 because he did not add the pictures to the eval directly

he asked me if he has to put them
which means he did not read the topic of the eval well , so he does not deserve to be in the top 5 , so i replaced him with dia